#8: How Do Mirror Neurons Trick Our Buying Decisions?
Could the part of your brain built for empathy also be your biggest liability?
Welcome to the eighth edition of the Marketing Mind Meld - a fun, new way to dive deeper into consumer growth, marketing psychology, and sometimes controversial opinions on the marketing world.
🧠 How Do Mirror Neurons Trick Our Buying Decisions?
How many of you look at this image and get an immediate urge to yawn?
How about looking at the following image and immediately feel a sense of sadness?
Does the following man releasing his hand make you nervous?
These are natural reactions.
But - in many ways, they make absolutely no sense.
Why do we get an urge to yawn, even if it’s not morning or we’re not explicitly tired?
Why do we feel a sense of deep loss or even the impulse for tears when we see Simba in a tragic situation, even if we’ve never experienced a loss of a loved one?
Why do we feel the plunging anxiety of hanging off a building even as we’re comfortably sitting in a desk chair?
It all comes down to two words that have changed the landscape of neuroscience and marketing for over 30 years: Mirror Neurons.
What are Mirror Neurons?
In 1992, Italian scientist Giacomo Rizzolatti and his team were studying the brains of monkeys to understand motor behaviors. Specifically, they were researching the premotor region of the brain, that registers activity when monkeys carry out certain gestures like moving and picking up objects.
One day, there was a twist.
Martin Lindstrom covers the discovery in his book, Buyology:
On one particularly hot summer afternoon, Rizzolatti and his team observed the strangest thing of all when one of Dr. Rizzolatti’s grad students returned to the lab after lunch holding an ice cream cone, and noticed that the macaque was staring at him, almost longingly. And as the grad student raised the cone to his mouth and took a tentative lick, the electronic monitor hooked up to the macaque’s premotor region fired—bripp, bripp, bripp.
The monkey was just sitting there. It hadn’t moved. It hadn’t even touched an ice cream cone.
Simply observing someone licking an ice cream cone prompted the monkey’s brain to mentally imitate the very same gesture, otherwise now known as the activation of a mirror neuron.
Simply put, mirror neurons are neurons that fire when an action is being performed and when that same action is being observed. We know they work in monkeys and there is considerable evidence over the years that they work in humans as well.
Think back to the above prompts: Do you wonder why you yawn? Why you well up in tears? Why you feel a sense of anxiety when observing someone else in a precarious situations? Chalk it up to mirror neurons.
It gets crazier: Mirror neurons are not only active when we see people performing certain actions but they can even get fired when we’re reading about someone performing it.
Imagine that I’m yawning right now. Just letting out a giant yawn. Embracing a reflex consisting of the simultaneous inhalation of air and the stretching of the eardrums, followed by an exhalation of breath. Also known as a yawn.
Are you yawning now? or even remotely tempted to yawn?
Not because you’re bored but simply because I typed the word yawn.
Why are Mirror Neurons important to Marketers?
So at the end of the day, what value does this provide to marketers?
Mirror neurons can often override consumer rational thinking and cause people to want to unconsciously imitate - and use - what its in front of them.
This concept of imitation is a huge factor in why we buy the things we do.
Imagine walking into a department store and seeing a perfect mannequin. Without even looking at the price of the clothing, you’re immediately seeing how you would look in it.
Imagine walking specifically into Abercrombie and Fitch and seeing the models playfully interacting on the walls - now you’re suddenly tempted to buy $12 boxer shorts just to get that similar feeling of bliss.
Do you recall the Apple ads for the Ipod? The silhouettes dancing with white headphones?
All mirror neurons tempting you to find the joy in dance.
Think about every GIF you’ve seen in an email.
You see someone comfortably sitting in a chair, by a fire - and before you know it, you’re imagining yourself stylish, warm, and comfortable.
Before we even knew what mirror neurons were, we had been using similar psychology to get people to buy things like cigarettes.
Here’s an ad from the 1960s for a cigarette with a simple premise: you’ll have love, laughter, and joy from Viceroy. Nobody questioned it’s health impacts - the desire to experience this same joy overrode simple logic.
Tips for marketers thinking through mirror neurons and imitation: Consider your audience.
How much can they empathize with the emotional pull in your content?
How valuable will your product be after 2-3 months once the emotional pull is gone?
Think back to Abercrombie - while you’re in the store with its rugged scent and playful models, how valuable is that purchase going to be six months down the road?
The mirror neurons might work once - but eventually they will be replaced by rational evidence that this product is not enduring enough to last through the initial imitation.
I love thinking through applications of mirror neurons and their relevance in consumer apps we use today - there will definitely be lots more to dive into with future iterations of the newsletter, especially with regards to current events.
Shoot me a note if you see any of this in your current day-to-day consumer marketing!
🏆 Meld Musings
Discovered an amazing artist through Twitter who makes animated gifs
Paul Graham talks about the role of conformism in movements
Crowdsourced and got two amazing new plants for my apartment 🌱
Check out my friends’ podcast Two Bacons in Love where Sam and Aaron talk about their relationships and multiple perspectives as Asian-Americans
Thinking about this quote from Brain Pickings: "The best ideas come to us when we stop actively trying to coax the muse into manifesting and let the fragments of experience float around our unconscious mind in order to click into new combinations."
As always, feel free to let me know if there’s anything else you’d love to see from me or the Mind Meld.
Until next time,
If you enjoyed this issue, hit the like button below and I’ll keep similar ones coming!